The Year of the Flood by Margaret Atwood - 2009 Dec
Meeting:
We met at the Natural Start Bakery near Mission/Hamilton. Really good location, and you can reserve the top floor for things like...a book group! I got there 15 minutes late as a result of driving directly from Seattle post-Christmas celebration, but they were kind enough to wait. Despite the fact that we had picked these dates 2 months ago, only two other girls (Megan and Jessica) showed up, and nobody else let us know they weren't coming...weird. Holiday bustle, I guess. So I didn't get the green tea I was craving, but next time I WILL! We had a lot to talk about for this book. It presented much more tangible topics than The Devil in the White City. One thing I remember was strong disagreements surfacing regarding the male characters. After reading this book, I assumed that the male characters were mistakenly one-dimensional, or left mysteriously unfinished in an attempt to shift focus to our two "heroines". But both Megan and Jessica have read Atwood before and know that she is a bit of a feminist, and that this specific inattention to detail is likely deliberate and a usual pattern for her. I wonder how my second reading of this literature, especially in regards to males, would feel in comparison. But that wasn't the big debate...I found no sympathy with the males. I found them careless and hypocritical, wheras another member found a few to be likable (Zeb in particular because he seemed "protective"). These are the reasons why I love meeting with these girls. It's so wonderful to hash out some new perspectives and change your opinion (like I did about one-dimensional guys in this lit...I think I get it now and am excited for more Atwood!). Another topic was the organization. I'm not sure the other two enjoyed Adam One's sermons as much as I did. Megan did look up all of the saints mentioned and came up with some interesting results via Google. I didn't even think of it (not like me at all). I find if I want to look things up online it's because I'm bored out of my mind at a book, or so enthralled by it I don't have time to put it down at all. The Year of the Flood fell into the latter category. Jessica had great topics of discussion. We talked for awhile about the environmental aspects and whether or not it should affect our lives. We also wondered aloud at the state of the world and whether or not we would get to this point (in our lifetimes or past them). We didn't talk as much as I had anticipated about the ending. There, again, we disagreed a bit. It was found to be unfinished in one's eyes, and in another's a satisfying and hopeful conclusion. But we all agreed on one thing: we are fascinated by the blue people and hope that they are a substantial part of Oryx and Crake.
Final:
I refused to go first, but I had decided to give this book an 8 out of 10 before anyone else spoke. We had another 8 and a 9.5. On this we all agreed: a GREAT book!
Next:
Well...we don't exactly know. Since there were only three of us (and one won't even live in the states for the next meeting) we felt uncomfortable picking the next book for all. We have three on the list that I will post separately. I'll keep them on the TO READ list until we've checked them off!
Showing posts with label 2009. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2009. Show all posts
Tuesday, December 22, 2009
Monday, December 14, 2009
Reading The Year of the Flood
The Year of the Flood by Margaret Atwood - 2009 Dec
Reading:
I finished this book in days. Maybe the cold weather contributed (fireplace + white tea + blanket = book!), but I just flew through this one. The story is a post-apocalyptic (or maybe just apocalyptic, depending on your outlook) setting years in the future, when "the social compact is wearing as thin as environmental stability". Atwood tells the story of two women who have a past connection to a very active and rigid green organization and their struggle with coming to the fact that the rest of the human population just might be extinct. So we bounce between past and present and between our two women (Ren and Toby). Decidedly unlike The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson, these women have a solid overlap to justify writing them into the same book...not just that they happened to be in the same city during a fair (see previous post regarding that). We also get a bonus...a third perspective from a spiritual environmentalist who has turned eco-friendliness into a religion. The Tolkein-like "poems" I noted upon finding this book are actually songs, and I hear that there is actually a recording. I love the interactivity that idea presents. I hope they're huge "O Fortuna"-style choral arrangements. But I doubt it. I definitely intend to find the CD at some point.
This book is probably not something I would pick up off of the shelves based on the jacket summary, but the cover art is a bit more intriguing, I suppose. Anyway, I really found myself focusing in on Ren. The jacket summary describes her as a "young dancer locked inside the high-end sex club Scales and Tails", so obviously that's why I connected with her (kidding). I think it may have been that we are just closer in age. I'm curious to see which woman each book club member latched onto. I didn't look up one word during this novel. I found its syntax and vocabulary to be very tangible and accessible despite the otherworldly setting. But the author did create words. Toby, for example, is trapped in a spa called AnooYoo. There are gene-splices proliferating in this world, such as a liobam (lion+lamb, to force the scriptural prophecy) and the rakunk (racoon+skunk, I think?). This deliberately-dumbed wordplay is sprinkled through the novel and after awhile I took pride in the fact that they did not trip me up and I was able to immediately discern new combinations. So that made up for the fact that my dictionary didn't have to be close at hand (something I usually despise in any lit).
I am undecided about how the environmental aspect affected me. I try to be "green", but not when it affects my budget. Organic foods with completely recycled/recyclable packaging might be okay with your wallet, but mine would throw a fit. There are obviously lessons to be learned in this book, which is why I'm excited for our group meeting to flesh that particular opinion out. These types of books with overt discussions are great for our group. We'll likely be saving the big spiritual/religious/sexuality/apocalyptic/the point to life/etc. topics for further down the road haha
Despite the gloomy outlook, the novel's end is decidedly positive. That caught me by surprise. The female characters were really colorful and dimensional, but I lacked that clarity and exploration in any male counterpart. I guess the mystery of those gentlemen is intriguing, but I definitely avoided investing in them after it became apparent that I would never know an answer (it's probably a tough balance to achieve, and one that translates into acting, I imagine).
I got on Amazon to read the summary, and in reviews I saw words like "masterpiece" thrown around in relation to Atwood's other works, so I wonder if that's true. I'm definitely going to get into her other titles and make up my own mind about that lofty claim. I would bet, though, that masterpiece might be just the word to describe this book.
Reading:
I finished this book in days. Maybe the cold weather contributed (fireplace + white tea + blanket = book!), but I just flew through this one. The story is a post-apocalyptic (or maybe just apocalyptic, depending on your outlook) setting years in the future, when "the social compact is wearing as thin as environmental stability". Atwood tells the story of two women who have a past connection to a very active and rigid green organization and their struggle with coming to the fact that the rest of the human population just might be extinct. So we bounce between past and present and between our two women (Ren and Toby). Decidedly unlike The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson, these women have a solid overlap to justify writing them into the same book...not just that they happened to be in the same city during a fair (see previous post regarding that). We also get a bonus...a third perspective from a spiritual environmentalist who has turned eco-friendliness into a religion. The Tolkein-like "poems" I noted upon finding this book are actually songs, and I hear that there is actually a recording. I love the interactivity that idea presents. I hope they're huge "O Fortuna"-style choral arrangements. But I doubt it. I definitely intend to find the CD at some point.
This book is probably not something I would pick up off of the shelves based on the jacket summary, but the cover art is a bit more intriguing, I suppose. Anyway, I really found myself focusing in on Ren. The jacket summary describes her as a "young dancer locked inside the high-end sex club Scales and Tails", so obviously that's why I connected with her (kidding). I think it may have been that we are just closer in age. I'm curious to see which woman each book club member latched onto. I didn't look up one word during this novel. I found its syntax and vocabulary to be very tangible and accessible despite the otherworldly setting. But the author did create words. Toby, for example, is trapped in a spa called AnooYoo. There are gene-splices proliferating in this world, such as a liobam (lion+lamb, to force the scriptural prophecy) and the rakunk (racoon+skunk, I think?). This deliberately-dumbed wordplay is sprinkled through the novel and after awhile I took pride in the fact that they did not trip me up and I was able to immediately discern new combinations. So that made up for the fact that my dictionary didn't have to be close at hand (something I usually despise in any lit).
I am undecided about how the environmental aspect affected me. I try to be "green", but not when it affects my budget. Organic foods with completely recycled/recyclable packaging might be okay with your wallet, but mine would throw a fit. There are obviously lessons to be learned in this book, which is why I'm excited for our group meeting to flesh that particular opinion out. These types of books with overt discussions are great for our group. We'll likely be saving the big spiritual/religious/sexuality/apocalyptic/the point to life/etc. topics for further down the road haha
Despite the gloomy outlook, the novel's end is decidedly positive. That caught me by surprise. The female characters were really colorful and dimensional, but I lacked that clarity and exploration in any male counterpart. I guess the mystery of those gentlemen is intriguing, but I definitely avoided investing in them after it became apparent that I would never know an answer (it's probably a tough balance to achieve, and one that translates into acting, I imagine).
I got on Amazon to read the summary, and in reviews I saw words like "masterpiece" thrown around in relation to Atwood's other works, so I wonder if that's true. I'm definitely going to get into her other titles and make up my own mind about that lofty claim. I would bet, though, that masterpiece might be just the word to describe this book.
Labels:
2009,
Margaret Atwood,
Reading,
The Year of the Flood
Sunday, November 22, 2009
Finding The Year of the Flood
The Year of the Flood by Margaret Atwood - 2009 Dec
Finding:
I went to a locally owned bookstore this time
(Auntie's, on Main & Washington). It temporarily satisfied my need to support local business. This bookstore is never short on old-world charm and solid advice from employees, which I love. (Is it 4 stories? 5??) I found out that the book is only in hardback now, which bummed me out. I try to buy paperback...don't ask me why, ask my wallet. It was published in September 2009, so on the upside there are many on the shelves. Jessica is facilitating December, and I expected 3 classics to choose from. Initially, I was sad we weren't delving into old lit, but after her 3 summaries I was really excited about our choices. I was pleased with the choice of this book in particular, since I had heard of the author (Margaret Atwood). I know she wrote Oryx and Crake, but that's all I could tangibly come up with. This book is supposedly an independent follow-up. In the store, there were several titles on the shelves and I learned this author is quite prolific. That makes me happy; if I like this book, I have a large authorial library to delve into later on. I was also quite excited because I really enjoy dystopian themes...for some maniacal end or other. The book itself is quite large, but the print is absolutely huge. During my usual preliminary flip-through, I noted a lack of illustrations (as the child in me cried), but format suggests several poems or songs a la Tolkien...
I am SO excited about this book, I'm going to get started asap!
Finding:
I went to a locally owned bookstore this time
(Auntie's, on Main & Washington). It temporarily satisfied my need to support local business. This bookstore is never short on old-world charm and solid advice from employees, which I love. (Is it 4 stories? 5??) I found out that the book is only in hardback now, which bummed me out. I try to buy paperback...don't ask me why, ask my wallet. It was published in September 2009, so on the upside there are many on the shelves. Jessica is facilitating December, and I expected 3 classics to choose from. Initially, I was sad we weren't delving into old lit, but after her 3 summaries I was really excited about our choices. I was pleased with the choice of this book in particular, since I had heard of the author (Margaret Atwood). I know she wrote Oryx and Crake, but that's all I could tangibly come up with. This book is supposedly an independent follow-up. In the store, there were several titles on the shelves and I learned this author is quite prolific. That makes me happy; if I like this book, I have a large authorial library to delve into later on. I was also quite excited because I really enjoy dystopian themes...for some maniacal end or other. The book itself is quite large, but the print is absolutely huge. During my usual preliminary flip-through, I noted a lack of illustrations (as the child in me cried), but format suggests several poems or songs a la Tolkien...I am SO excited about this book, I'm going to get started asap!
Labels:
2009,
Finding,
Margaret Atwood,
The Year of the Flood
Complete: The Devil in the White City
The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson - 2009 Nov
I'm not sure how I should make these posts flow, so here starts an experiment...or maybe my own novel...sorry I'm so long winded. I think in the future, I'll try separating these sections.
Finding the Book:
Started off with buying the book, I suppose. We decided that we'd like to do fiction, and had a list of 4 or 5 going. None of us had a solid opinion, so I honestly just picked one. The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson. I thought the tagline to be cheesy...something about murder, magic and mayhem at the world's greatest fair...but attributed that to overzealous editors. I went to a corporate bookstore (ugh) just because it was close and I got lazy. I scanned the fiction shelves, but no book. Since the store was closing, I asked a clerk to make the process quicker. She recognized the title and shepherded me over to the History section...?! Turns out, The Devil in the White City is a non-fiction item. Curious as to why we didn't pick up on this, I purchased it (and noted the small paper signs denoting that it was an employee favorite). The checker also small talked me; she hadn't read it, but heard a lot about it. She asked a few questions about book club, but fearing a corporate club offer with a fee, I deflected.
For some reason, I always flip through a book quickly when I get it. I suppose it's the child in me checking for super cool illustrations. To my adolescent delight, a few b&w photos were layered in. I noted an extensive source guide, bibliography, and index. A true nonfiction? Also (not sure where to categorize this random observation), everywhere I carted the book in public, someone would notice the cover and tell me their opinion about it. I ran into more positive former readers than negative, which motivated me to keep reading.
Reading:
The first 100 pages was like MUD for me to get though. Seeing no in-text citations, I noted that this book deliberately read like a fiction. I oscillated back and forth for awhile, finally deciding that the big-chain bookstore had categorized it correctly in History. The book began in the late-1800s (a period of great interest to me) and essentially bounced back and forth between two central characters. In short, an architect attempting to construct the world's greatest fair in Chicago, and a serial killer capitalizing on the opportunity of incoming murderable material. The author established his penchant for careful research early on...and took it too far early on as well, sometimes over-accentuating a small detail. For example, he would state a fact, insert a quote from a personal letter from any old Midwesterner, followed by a newspaper headline, followed by more musing upon said fact, and closed by a quote from a diary entry from another random Midwesterner. I felt bombarded sometimes by character names and/or source materials (I wished most were simply cited in the final indices). BUT this is why I love book club; had I been reading this for personal pleasure, the 100 page rule would have kicked in and I would have tossed it aside for a Shakespeare or something. Book club forces me to keep trudging even when I feel like quitting, if nothing else to tell them WHY I might have hated a piece of lit. But in the long run, I ended up enjoying this book for a lot of reasons. Despite the lack of narrative style that I craved (in my own personal opinion, of course), I always delight in intellectual provocation. When I was a child, I used to read Paul Harvey's The Rest of the Story. CONSTANTLY. They are very short stories with the key fact in the last words (read a few on Amazon, you'll see why as a child I LOVED them). Anyway, this book was like a long-winded Paul Harvey story. There are links to Disney, Frank Lloyd Wright, Shredded Wheat, PBR, the invention of the zipper, the USA's answer to the Eiffel Tower (I won't spoil this one)...on and on. I LOVE that stuff! One thing that I was disappointed with, however, was the lack of new vocabulary. I read with a pencil and a dictionary. ALWAYS. I write definitions in the margins, but I'll tell you how many words I looked up...5.
Also, I found myself particularly entranced by the serial killer chapters (morbid, I know). The book was zippered up, alternating chapters between architect and murderer. I couldn't get through the architect chapters quickly enough to get back to the criminal. His name was H. H. Holmes (well, one of his names...you'll see!). Immediately I thought of Humbert Humbert, and I was not disappointed by this coincidental parallel.
In general, the note I wrote the most in the margins was "delusions of grandeur?"
Meeting:
We met at the Rocket, a great local coffee shop and bakery. Attendees were Megan, Crystal, Minda, Jessica (and a foreign friend visiting for the time being) and me. (and I? Grammatically, not sure...moving on...). Perfect number of girls for a good discussion, upon reflection. Somehow I wound up facilitating, so I printed sets of questions that I found online. I'll link to them (reposting might be too long; let me know if you want me to repost in comments). One set was by the publisher, one set was random?, and the other was a general question list that applies to any book. I was NOT strict by any means with questions, just brought one up when there was a lull in the conversation. Everyone finished the book, which is a good sign. The general consensus was that perhaps the author wanted to write a book about Holmes (aka serial killer) but did not have enough material to churn a book out on him alone. We all found him compelling the read. Four of us agreed about the first 100 pages being the obstacle. The questions that I brought up regarding the application of this piece of literature to real life didn't seem to light fires under anyone (Ex: Much was made about classical vs modern architecture, and no one had a solid opinion regarding it.). I wondered aloud what the author was telling us, what his final opinion regarding his own worldview, but only heard broad generalizations. Personally, I saw a striking parallel between the control and organization of this book, and the manic control issues H. H. Holmes displayed. There's an opportunity to distort the truth with the nonfiction/source material aspect of this book, and the same is true regarding the memoir/confession of the murderer. Both authors seem to display the same tendencies regarding the driver's seat (That thought doesn't make sense, but maybe I'll expand and refine it in the future).
Final:
I dishonestly ranked the book highest, purely out of nicety. I had to be the example, and didn't want anyone to think I hated it, particularly in the first meeting of the group that I helped start. Didn't want to end on a sour note, I guess. Anyway, rankings were (I think) 5, 6, 6, 7 and 8. Not poor, but not stellar. I would recommend this book to the avid nonfiction reader, or to someone that feels confined by academia (maybe a bored college student). But not to a book club looking for deep, truthful discussions...unless the book club has ONLY read fiction for a solid year or more. It would be a good way to rock the boat in that case.
I'm not sure how I should make these posts flow, so here starts an experiment...or maybe my own novel...sorry I'm so long winded. I think in the future, I'll try separating these sections.
Finding the Book:
Started off with buying the book, I suppose. We decided that we'd like to do fiction, and had a list of 4 or 5 going. None of us had a solid opinion, so I honestly just picked one. The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson. I thought the tagline to be cheesy...something about murder, magic and mayhem at the world's greatest fair...but attributed that to overzealous editors. I went to a corporate bookstore (ugh) just because it was close and I got lazy. I scanned the fiction shelves, but no book. Since the store was closing, I asked a clerk to make the process quicker. She recognized the title and shepherded me over to the History section...?! Turns out, The Devil in the White City is a non-fiction item. Curious as to why we didn't pick up on this, I purchased it (and noted the small paper signs denoting that it was an employee favorite). The checker also small talked me; she hadn't read it, but heard a lot about it. She asked a few questions about book club, but fearing a corporate club offer with a fee, I deflected.
For some reason, I always flip through a book quickly when I get it. I suppose it's the child in me checking for super cool illustrations. To my adolescent delight, a few b&w photos were layered in. I noted an extensive source guide, bibliography, and index. A true nonfiction? Also (not sure where to categorize this random observation), everywhere I carted the book in public, someone would notice the cover and tell me their opinion about it. I ran into more positive former readers than negative, which motivated me to keep reading.
Reading:
The first 100 pages was like MUD for me to get though. Seeing no in-text citations, I noted that this book deliberately read like a fiction. I oscillated back and forth for awhile, finally deciding that the big-chain bookstore had categorized it correctly in History. The book began in the late-1800s (a period of great interest to me) and essentially bounced back and forth between two central characters. In short, an architect attempting to construct the world's greatest fair in Chicago, and a serial killer capitalizing on the opportunity of incoming murderable material. The author established his penchant for careful research early on...and took it too far early on as well, sometimes over-accentuating a small detail. For example, he would state a fact, insert a quote from a personal letter from any old Midwesterner, followed by a newspaper headline, followed by more musing upon said fact, and closed by a quote from a diary entry from another random Midwesterner. I felt bombarded sometimes by character names and/or source materials (I wished most were simply cited in the final indices). BUT this is why I love book club; had I been reading this for personal pleasure, the 100 page rule would have kicked in and I would have tossed it aside for a Shakespeare or something. Book club forces me to keep trudging even when I feel like quitting, if nothing else to tell them WHY I might have hated a piece of lit. But in the long run, I ended up enjoying this book for a lot of reasons. Despite the lack of narrative style that I craved (in my own personal opinion, of course), I always delight in intellectual provocation. When I was a child, I used to read Paul Harvey's The Rest of the Story. CONSTANTLY. They are very short stories with the key fact in the last words (read a few on Amazon, you'll see why as a child I LOVED them). Anyway, this book was like a long-winded Paul Harvey story. There are links to Disney, Frank Lloyd Wright, Shredded Wheat, PBR, the invention of the zipper, the USA's answer to the Eiffel Tower (I won't spoil this one)...on and on. I LOVE that stuff! One thing that I was disappointed with, however, was the lack of new vocabulary. I read with a pencil and a dictionary. ALWAYS. I write definitions in the margins, but I'll tell you how many words I looked up...5.
- refulgent: shining radiantly (page 12)
- miasma: noxious atmosphere, poisonous vapor (page 28)
- inculcate: teach by repetition; instill (page 39)
- obstreperous: noisily & stubbornly defiant (page 58)
- somnambulistic: sleepwalking (page 105)
In general, the note I wrote the most in the margins was "delusions of grandeur?"
Meeting:
We met at the Rocket, a great local coffee shop and bakery. Attendees were Megan, Crystal, Minda, Jessica (and a foreign friend visiting for the time being) and me. (and I? Grammatically, not sure...moving on...). Perfect number of girls for a good discussion, upon reflection. Somehow I wound up facilitating, so I printed sets of questions that I found online. I'll link to them (reposting might be too long; let me know if you want me to repost in comments). One set was by the publisher, one set was random?, and the other was a general question list that applies to any book. I was NOT strict by any means with questions, just brought one up when there was a lull in the conversation. Everyone finished the book, which is a good sign. The general consensus was that perhaps the author wanted to write a book about Holmes (aka serial killer) but did not have enough material to churn a book out on him alone. We all found him compelling the read. Four of us agreed about the first 100 pages being the obstacle. The questions that I brought up regarding the application of this piece of literature to real life didn't seem to light fires under anyone (Ex: Much was made about classical vs modern architecture, and no one had a solid opinion regarding it.). I wondered aloud what the author was telling us, what his final opinion regarding his own worldview, but only heard broad generalizations. Personally, I saw a striking parallel between the control and organization of this book, and the manic control issues H. H. Holmes displayed. There's an opportunity to distort the truth with the nonfiction/source material aspect of this book, and the same is true regarding the memoir/confession of the murderer. Both authors seem to display the same tendencies regarding the driver's seat (That thought doesn't make sense, but maybe I'll expand and refine it in the future).
Final:
I dishonestly ranked the book highest, purely out of nicety. I had to be the example, and didn't want anyone to think I hated it, particularly in the first meeting of the group that I helped start. Didn't want to end on a sour note, I guess. Anyway, rankings were (I think) 5, 6, 6, 7 and 8. Not poor, but not stellar. I would recommend this book to the avid nonfiction reader, or to someone that feels confined by academia (maybe a bored college student). But not to a book club looking for deep, truthful discussions...unless the book club has ONLY read fiction for a solid year or more. It would be a good way to rock the boat in that case.
Labels:
2009,
Erik Larson,
Final,
Finding,
meeting,
Reading,
The Devil in the White City
Sunday, October 11, 2009
New Girls!
The book club has existed for six months, actually...but as co-founders (hahaha) we felt it necessary to open the ranks. We lost a girl to Spain for study-abroad, and slowly a few others have just let life get in the way and stopped reading or attending. So against my better judgement, I posted an ad on Craigslist to see who would respond. I thought if nothing else, I could just remove the ad and ignore the emails I received in response thanks to Craigslist anonymous email policy. But the first two girls seemed nice and normal. And so did the next three...and the next six. So...I met a few. And we're meeting two more today! Super excited to get started again, especially with some new faces and (thank god) new perspectives!
I'm finding it difficult to keep track of our literature, so I'm creating this blog as a guideline.
I'm finding it difficult to keep track of our literature, so I'm creating this blog as a guideline.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)