Showing posts with label 2010. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2010. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Fight Club!

I proposed this book a year ago (whoa that seems like so long ago!), and now we're doing it for June! It seems odd to set it in our repertoire, given the overconsumption of...what, chick lit? No, not quite...but close. Women-centered literature, empowerment, romance, etc. Would Fight Club deign to be a part of our "usual"? Apparently so! I have to make myself read these slowly, otherwise I'm done in a day or two. I'm already a quarter of the way through...I may have to put it down. But I love it, I forgot how witty it is. A friend I had heard that Chuck Palahniuk has to work really hard to get something good, but I don't care anymore! I adore this book. I thought that after watching the movie I might have Brad Pitt and Edward Norton (a personal favorite of mine) floating through my psyche, but they have miraculously faded away. Which has never happened to me before! I am excited, and thought that I'd share...although, I feel like I'm drinking more.

joking.

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Meeting for Pope Joan

Pope Joan - May 2010

There were only four of us that met for Pope Joan this month, but it turned out to be a fun discussion. We've gone to most of the Rocket Bakeries here in town, and I didn't know there was one so far north. It was a good location! Turns out there are several print editions of this book, but we only knew this based on the questions with the author at the end of newer editions. They all had discussion questions, which is mostly nice...but some questions are a bit general/dumbed down/repetitive. We usually end up having good conversations, mostly without them. We all think it's possible a female Pope could have existed (conspiracy theorists!) and I think we all wished she could have ended up with Gerold (romantics!). I really enjoyed the structure of this book; simple & effective. I learned a TON about Catholicism (and Latin & Italian, believe it or not), and it sparked interest in those areas. I think after Lolita, this might be my favorite book club selection. One criticism that I kind of understood was that one reader couldn't latch onto the character, the story didn't draw her in enough. Which started this discussion...I really wished that Joan had a fault. Just one! There was nothing wrong with this girl! She was perfect! And I thought that contributed to her lack of humanity, which hinders our understanding & compassion (which I'm familiar with because of theatre).

Pope Joan
7.5, 8.8, 8.5, (me) 9

Member Suggestions
  • The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher by Kate Summerscale
  • Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte
  • Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk --- June 2010

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Ideas!

I think I'm facilitating next month? And if I'm not, I'm bringing my three choices anyway, just in case. I facilitated the first book soooo long ago because nobody else wanted to go first! As it happened, I didn't much care for the book (which doesn't need to be named outright...heh) BUT somebody else in the group did. And it put the books that I have liked so far in a much brighter contrast. Which 100% works for me.

Anyway. I've been compiling a list of books I've heard of for quite some time, and starring them if I hear of them again. Here's a partial list, in order as of right now. I can only bring three ideas to keep it simple. Our meeting is in less than a week, so things could change....

  • The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho (HATE these excerpts online, but I keep heraing about it and it's at the top of a lot of reader's lists, especially at readinggroupguides.com)
  • Daughter of Fortune by Isabel Allende (hear a lot about this author, but always different titles)
  • The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald (alright, confession: never read it, but probably should)
  • A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith (keep hearing about this on olivereader.com; sounds like our type of read)
  • Atonement by Ian McEwan (I liked On Chesil Beach, and I loved this movie!)
  • something, anything by Lionel Shriver

If you have any ideas, write them in the comments below...what is your favorite book???

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Ranks

Water for Elephants
9, 9, 9, 9, 8, 9.3, (me) 8

The Help
8.7, 8.6, 8, 8, (me) 8.5

Art of Racing in the Rain
9, 8.6, 7.5, 9, (me) 8

where has

...the time gone...It's really been 3 months since I posted? I am active in theatre, which takes up a ton of time in addition to a day job, but I haven't missed book club yet. I'll do some quick catch-up later...

Sunday, January 31, 2010

Finding Water for Elephants

I took a few days to buy this book, which isn't like me...but I found it used at Hastings. Super cheap! I was pleased to find it on a bestseller's table out front (the used copies were in the back). Flipping through the book I saw some great old circus photos (similar to the photo at left) and a list of discussion questions at the end. Sidenote: I will NEVER again even GLANCE at discussion questions. It ruined the end of The Time Traveler's Wife for me, just because I glanced at a question that named their unborn baby. That novel's parallel stories are climaxing toward two things; one storyline is going toward sex, and the married-couple-parallel is moving toward family. They are never sure if they can have a baby because of genetic complications, but the whole time I knew the answer which drove me bonkers! SO! No reading these Qs until I finish the book! Should make for an easy discussion if we run out of topics.

Meeting for The Reader

Meeting:
I was really excited about this meeting because I asked two new girls to join and Megan asked one (though she couldn't make it this time). We had several girls which really helped with our discussion! Lots of fun questions and opinions and coffee...made for a great Sunday!

We met on the top floor of the Natural Start Bakery again (and reserved for our next meeting...SUCH a good spot!). It's nice and cozy, and seems to be close enough to fit everyone's needs. There were six of us, which I felt might be the perfect number. Several girls still didn't show, but having this many people might be nice so there's no pressure to show if you just can't swing it.

About the book...I'm not sure we all felt it, though I got the feeling we were all proud to be able to put it on our I HAVE READ list! It was a really interesting novel with some difficult topics, but it may have been too aloof for us to grab onto. I thought I didn't feel urgency or suspense because I had seen the movie, but two others hadn't and they said the same thing before I had voiced that opinion. I can't put my finger on why we didn't hook in yet, but if I/we figure it out, I'll have to write it down. We did, however, enjoy some really cool discussions about WWII and the implications of living just after that ended. The guilt and process of moving on struck us in general. It's hard to understand because we feel so far removed already. It wasn't that long ago, but it is SO hard to imagine how it even occurred. Then we talked a lot about love and what it goes through; how resilient it can be. Surprisingly, the topic of age didn't really come up in a negative light. I'm becoming pretty socially liberal the more I get into the people around me, but I wasn't sure about the rest of the girls. Maybe it was an avoided topic, but I'd like to thing that we all kind of understood. Then again, after Lolita....well....maybe it didn't need to be brought up. Or maybe it's a gender thing. (Then again, I'm surprised we missed that angle. SHOOT!). Anyway, we all felt for Hannah in some way or another, and were grateful that we can talk about this book in the future!

Final:
The overall sores were 8, 7, 6.5, 6 (me), 6 and 5.5. Average = 6.5 (where 10 is high). Again, not dreadful, but not completely compelling either. I'm stoked for next month!

Saturday, January 23, 2010

Reading...The Reader

The Reader by Bernhard Schlink - Jan 2010

My titles suck...I use up all of my creativity elsewhere and by the time I get to stuff like this, I'm too lazy!

So the book started off quickly, but I found myself losing interest. I honestly 100% think it's my fault for seeing the movie. There are some huge plot points (huge spoilers here) that would have kept me interested...the illiteracy, the conviction, the suicide; one per "part". I hardly ever finish a book the day before we meet up, but this time the only pressure I felt was that of a deadline -- no plot suspense whatsoever. Had it not been for book club, this book may have not passed the 100 pages rule.

NOT that I hated it. I just didn't have that urgency or suspense to keep me going. There wasn't much to keep my interest as far as beautiful prose goes, or words that I got to look up. So it all should have been in the story.

I know some women haven't seen the movie, so I'll see if they lost interest or stayed intrigued.

Monday, December 28, 2009

Finding The Reader

The Reader by Bernhard Schlink - Jan 2010

Finding:
We finally decided on The Reader, though input lacked. So those of us that are enthusiastic did the picking this time! Fine by me! I found my copy at a used bookstore. I am surprised at how thin and small it is. I'm going to get through this one in no time! I assumed the edition I found would have a photo of Kate Winslet on the cover, and sure enough...it's a "movie tie-in". Which ends at the cover art, as far as I can tell. I was excited to get going on this one, so I thought I'd read a chapter before bed. And I read five. The outset isn't slow at all, and there's almost no use for exposition. So it definitely hooks you immediately! Can't wait for our next discussion...